Romila Thapar’s recent remarks on the relationship between colonial historiography and Hindutva interpretations of Indian history raise a fundamental question concerning the production, interpretation, and political appropriation of historical knowledge. Her central contention—that contemporary Hindutva readings often reproduce interpretive assumptions inherited from colonial scholarship—invites a reconsideration of what it means to decolonise Indian history. The significance of this argument lies not simply in its critique of religious nationalism, but in its insistence that the writing of history must be distinguished from the political mobilisation of the past.
Colonial historiography did not merely document the Indian past; it also organised it through conceptual frameworks derived from European intellectual traditions and colonial administrative imperatives. James Mill’s periodisation of Indian history into Hindu, Muslim, and British phases is an especially revealing example. By making religious affiliation the principal organising principle of historical change, this framework encouraged the representation of Indian society as a succession of religiously distinct and antagonistic communities. Such periodisation obscured the complex relationships among political authority, economic interests, social hierarchies, regional formations, and cultural exchange. Thapar’s argument is therefore important insofar as it demonstrates that colonial categories can survive the formal end of colonial rule and acquire new political significance within ostensibly indigenous accounts of national history.
The persistence of these categories in contemporary historical narratives raises a paradox about decolonisation. A historical interpretation does not become decolonial simply because it celebrates indigenous traditions, foregrounds ancient achievements, or rejects European scholarship. If it retains the colonial tendency to treat religious communities as internally homogeneous, historically continuous, and fundamentally antagonistic, it may reproduce the very assumptions it claims to overcome. Decolonisation must consequently involve a critical examination of the conceptual apparatus of historical writing, rather than merely a reversal of its evaluative conclusions. This position is consistent with Thapar’s earlier scholarship on ideology and the interpretation of early Indian history, in which she examined the influence of colonial experience and modern nationalism on historical reconstruction (Thapar, 1982).
The example of the Battle of Haldighati, invoked in the report, illustrates the methodological consequences of reducing historical conflicts to religious antagonism. The political and military contest involving Maharana Pratap and the Mughal forces cannot be adequately understood through a binary opposition between Hindu resistance and Muslim conquest alone. The participation of Afghan soldiers in Pratap’s forces and the command of the Mughal army by the Rajput ruler Man Singh complicate such a representation. These details do not establish that religion was irrelevant to the conflict; rather, they demonstrate that religious identity cannot, without further evidence, serve as a sufficient explanation of political allegiance. Territorial claims, dynastic interests, imperial expansion, strategic calculations, and relations of patronage must also enter the analysis. The broader historiographical lesson is that historical explanation requires attention to the interaction of multiple causes rather than the retrospective imposition of a single, politically convenient narrative.
Thapar’s emphasis on inscriptions and other material evidence is equally important. Literary and religious texts remain indispensable sources for reconstructing early Indian history, but they must be examined in relation to their authorship, intended audiences, historical contexts, and social purposes. Inscriptions, archaeological remains, coins, and other material evidence can illuminate aspects of political authority, economic organisation, social differentiation, and regional interaction that prescriptive or normative texts may not adequately represent. No source, however, is transparent or self-explanatory. Inscriptions, too, may articulate royal claims, legitimise authority, or selectively represent social realities. The methodological imperative is therefore not to privilege one category of evidence absolutely, but to triangulate independent sources, evaluate their limitations, and test competing interpretations against the available record.
A further implication concerns the relationship between historical scholarship and contemporary political identity. Nationalist narratives frequently seek to establish a continuous collective subject extending from antiquity to the present. Yet the modern nation-state is not a timeless category that can simply be projected onto earlier societies. Premodern identities were shaped by overlapping affiliations involving locality, language, caste, sect, lineage, political allegiance, and religious practice. These affiliations could coexist, compete, and change over time. Treating them as expressions of an unchanging national or religious community risks converting historical diversity into an artificial narrative of continuity. At the same time, recognising the historical construction of modern national identities does not require denying the existence of older cultural connections or collective memories. It requires distinguishing those connections from the modern political categories through which they are subsequently interpreted.
Nevertheless, Thapar’s intervention also invites a broader reflexive question: can historiography be adequately decolonised without critically examining the assumptions of every modern interpretive tradition, including secular and nationalist scholarship? Colonial historiography, postcolonial critique, Marxist analysis, cultural history, and religious-nationalist interpretations all employ conceptual frameworks that require scrutiny. Their claims should be assessed through transparent methods, engagement with primary sources, and openness to counter-evidence. No historian or interpretive school should be exempt from such scrutiny. This qualification does not establish an equivalence between all historical approaches; rather, it underscores the need to evaluate specific claims according to their evidentiary support and explanatory adequacy.
Indeed, the strongest defence of historical pluralism is not that every interpretation is equally valid, but that interpretations must remain open to contestation. Religious traditions are internally diverse, and their historical development cannot be reduced to a singular civilisational essence. Likewise, conflicts between rulers belonging to different religious communities cannot automatically be interpreted as conflicts between those communities as a whole. Nor should the existence of political alliances across religious boundaries be used to deny the significance of religious ideas where evidence demonstrates their relevance. Historical explanation requires contextual discrimination rather than predetermined conclusions.
Ultimately, Thapar’s intervention highlights the distinction between history as a critical inquiry into the past and history as an instrument for legitimising contemporary political projects. The former depends on evidence, contextualisation, debate, and the revisability of conclusions; the latter tends to select and organise evidence in accordance with an established account of collective identity. The challenge facing Indian historiography is therefore not to replace one authoritative narrative with another, but to sustain a methodological culture in which inherited categories can be questioned and historical claims remain answerable to evidence.
Decolonising Indian history, in this sense, is an ongoing intellectual process rather than a completed political achievement. It requires the critical reassessment of colonial classifications, the incorporation of new archaeological and epigraphic evidence, and a sustained engagement with the plurality of India’s historical experiences. Most importantly, it requires resisting the temptation to make the past conform to the political demands of the present. A democratic historiography does not depend on a single, uncontested account of national origins; it depends on the institutional and intellectual conditions that permit disagreement, revision, and the coexistence of competing interpretations. Thapar’s argument is thus a reminder that the integrity of historical scholarship rests not on the production of a definitive collective identity, but on the disciplined pursuit of historically defensible explanations.
References
Thapar, Romila. 1968. “Interpretations of Ancient Indian History.” History and Theory 7 (3): 318–335.
Thapar, Romila. 1982. “Ideology and the Interpretation of Early Indian History.” Review 5 (3): 389–411.
Thapar, Romila. 2008. “Imagined Religious Communities? Ancient History and the Modern Search for a Hindu Identity.” Modern Asian Studies. Published online 28 November 2008.
Primary news source: “Hindutva Reading Builds on Colonial Interpretations of Indian History: Romila Thapar.” The Hindu, October 2026.
Leave a Reply